Attn: NuCanoe Forum Members:
The NuCanoe Forum, like fishing, hunting, paddling, etc., is about having fun and enjoying what you love. While it is a fine place to voice concerns and share problems, it is not a place for excess negativity, personal criticism, or disrespect to other members. Individuals who make the Forum less enjoyable for everyone else will be removed. Thank you for keeping the Forum a great place to share, learn, and connect with others. ~ Cheers, Blake

Please consider registering
guest

Log In Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search:

— Forum Scope —



— Match —



— Forum Options —




Wildcard usage:
*  matches any number of characters    %  matches exactly one character

Minimum search word length is 4 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

Topic RSS
Trolling motor shaft length for the frontier?
December 26, 2012
4:05 pm
garyo3
Member
Forum Posts: 26
Member Since:
July 9, 2012
Offline

Is a 18 inch shaft long enough to work properly on the frontier, I was looking at the motor guide 46# vari-max trolling motor? I also found a trolling motor on boatstogo.com it is a 26 inch shaft and has 55lbs of thrust. It has some neat features and the price is really attractive. Does anybody have any experience with theses motors they would like to share? I would prefer the variable speed over the 5 speed forward and three speed reverse model but $150.00 difference pays for the battery and then some. Any input is appreciated as I am in full shopping mode. I like the bass yaks but $1,000.00 for the kit is just to much and I still have to buy a battery.

Garyo3

December 26, 2012
5:00 pm
CrappieFly
Athens, Al.
Member
Forum Posts: 2571
Member Since:
June 27, 2012
Online

Gary,

I have a MK 55lb 5 for. speed/ 3 rev. speed 36″ shaft, it does a good job on the Frontier. I also have a friend that has a MK 40 lb on a Classic and he says it is more motor then he needs, he never runs it on high speed. I don’t have to run mine on high speed either and it pushes it just fine.

I have read some bad reviews on the Motor Guide Vari-Max trolling motors, they are saying they don’t hold up very good.

IMO, you would be better off going with the 5/3 speed set up on a trolling motor. And I would have to say, any TM from a 40#- 55# will do a good job.

James, Team NuCanoe Alabama
December 26, 2012
7:06 pm
garyo3
Member
Forum Posts: 26
Member Since:
July 9, 2012
Offline

Thanks c/fly if you have a chance check the motor out on boatstogo.com and let me know your thoughts. Not trying to advertise for that site but would really appreciate any info I can get on those motors. The tilting head and 26 inch shaft length are what I like.

Garyo3

December 27, 2012
12:18 am
RayBorbon
Member
Forum Posts: 18
Member Since:
August 12, 2012
Offline

Hi guys. Where exactly are you putting your batteries? I would imagine up front. If you were riding two in the Frontier for example then it seems like the battery should go into where the front storage area is located. Are you using a group 24 battery and does it fit in there?

December 27, 2012
2:54 am
Pcolaboy
Lake Texoma/Tyndall AFB/Gulf Shore ALA
Member
Forum Posts: 63
Member Since:
September 5, 2012
Offline

18″ is fine, that what I cut mine down to, I’m running a 30# 5/3, with no problem, size 27 batt. , up front, fish by my self. This is an awesome set up, I fish all day and cover many a mile. mikeSmileWink

December 27, 2012
3:21 am
ack-yak
Little Egg Harbor Township, New Jersey
Member
Forum Posts: 2605
Member Since:
June 30, 2012
Offline

I, too, fish single with an electric motor. My seat is positioned with my feet at midship. I’ve placed the battery right up tight to the seat. Steering is done with flexible joint extension handle. The balance is just about perfect. This configuration allows the front deck to stay clean, no wires running anywhere up there. When I drive , I just turn abit, steer with right hand and rest the tiller on the battery box when done running, which makes it really easy to reach and start moving again.

A couple times when I’ve run aground{I know it’s never happened to anyone else) I spin around, slid my butt onto the battery box, and scoot the rest of the way back to the motor to lift it up and lay it down. GOD BLESS FRONTIER STABILITY, cause I’ve done that in a little bit of a chop……COULDN’T DO THAT IN MANY OTHER BOATS….
Oh, I’m using an Endura/Minn-cota 30″ shaft
ack-yak Bob

I’m in Shape……Round’s a Shape…..!!

"I'm in shape.....round's a shape!!!" Team NuCanoe-South Jersey
December 27, 2012
5:33 am
CrappieFly
Athens, Al.
Member
Forum Posts: 2571
Member Since:
June 27, 2012
Online

I use a group 27 battery, but a group 24 will work ok.
If you will look under “Rigging and Outfitting” I have a post there, (1 Winter Project Done), with pics of how I rig mine. Most all wires are hidden, battery is up front. Also I am planning on cutting my shaft down some, just not done it yet.

James, Team NuCanoe Alabama
December 27, 2012
2:56 pm
NukeCanoe
Northwest Ohio
Admin
Forum Posts: 1606
Member Since:
June 25, 2012
Offline

ack-yak said

I, too, fish single with an electric motor. My seat is positioned with my feet at midship. I’ve placed the battery right up tight to the seat. Steering is done with flexible joint extension handle. The balance is just about perfect. This configuration allows the front deck to stay clean, no wires running anywhere up there. When I drive , I just turn abit, steer with right hand and rest the tiller on the battery box when done running, which makes it really easy to reach and start moving again.

A couple times when I’ve run aground{I know it’s never happened to anyone else) I spin around, slid my butt onto the battery box, and scoot the rest of the way back to the motor to lift it up and lay it down. GOD BLESS FRONTIER STABILITY, cause I’ve done that in a little bit of a chop……COULDN’T DO THAT IN MANY OTHER BOATS….
Oh, I’m using an Endura/Minn-cota 30″ shaft
ack-yak Bob

I’m in Shape……Round’s a Shape…..!!

I too belong to the Shape club after these bountiful holidays!

Team NuCanoe Ohio - http://www.kayakcorral.com/ - http://www.steelheadshop.com/
December 27, 2012
3:04 pm
CrappieFly
Athens, Al.
Member
Forum Posts: 2571
Member Since:
June 27, 2012
Online

NukeCanoe said

ack-yak said

I, too, fish single with an electric motor. My seat is positioned with my feet at midship. I’ve placed the battery right up tight to the seat. Steering is done with flexible joint extension handle. The balance is just about perfect. This configuration allows the front deck to stay clean, no wires running anywhere up there. When I drive , I just turn abit, steer with right hand and rest the tiller on the battery box when done running, which makes it really easy to reach and start moving again.

A couple times when I’ve run aground{I know it’s never happened to anyone else) I spin around, slid my butt onto the battery box, and scoot the rest of the way back to the motor to lift it up and lay it down. GOD BLESS FRONTIER STABILITY, cause I’ve done that in a little bit of a chop……COULDN’T DO THAT IN MANY OTHER BOATS….
Oh, I’m using an Endura/Minn-cota 30″ shaft
ack-yak Bob

I’m in Shape……Round’s a Shape…..!!

I too belong to the Shape club after these bountiful holidays!

After the “bountiful holidays” I think we all belong the the “Shape Club”. Laugh

James, Team NuCanoe Alabama
December 28, 2012
1:25 pm
garyo3
Member
Forum Posts: 26
Member Since:
July 9, 2012
Offline
10

Thank you for the info. IS THE GENERAL CONSENSUS THAT A 30LB THRUST MOTOR WILL BE SUFFICENT FOR THE FRONTIER??? This is the only one they offer in a 30 inch shaft. The new endura C-2 can be bought for $100.00 which leaves me using the extra $ to upgrade to a AGM battery.

Garyo3

December 28, 2012
2:16 pm
ack-yak
Little Egg Harbor Township, New Jersey
Member
Forum Posts: 2605
Member Since:
June 30, 2012
Offline

Garyo3, That’s the motor I have and it’s fine for 90% of the fishing I do. I’m in local lakes (Small ponds to you Southern guys) most of the time with no current, just sometimes a little wind…..it’s good there. BUT when I’m in the local tidal waters I have to tell you it is barely adequate in fighing a strong tidal flow & strong wind. My guess is, in a running river, you could use a bit more thrust.(remember I’m talking a STRONG CURRENT & HIGH WIND)
It’s possible that Dick’s Sporting Goods may have discount coupons for that motor. For the price and general use it’s not bad at all. Mines been in saltwater and washed each time, and hasn’t corroded at all.
Hope this helps, maybe some others will chime in with more info…. ack-yak Bob

"I'm in shape.....round's a shape!!!" Team NuCanoe-South Jersey
January 6, 2013
7:43 pm
big irish
Guest
12
Awaiting Moderation

April 4, 2013
2:48 am
digitalh3lix
Member
Forum Posts: 163
Member Since:
August 14, 2012
Offline
13

I was running my frontier with a endura 30 minn kota with an optima battery. Lasted around 2hrs at full throttle then id die out. Both motor and battery was in the back, no problems with weight.

Dave, Team Nucanoe Massachusetts "BOSTON STRONG"
April 4, 2013
2:53 am
NukeCanoe
Northwest Ohio
Admin
Forum Posts: 1606
Member Since:
June 25, 2012
Offline
14

Helix,

Did you have all your tackle and gear in the back as well? Just wondering, I bought the material to run the battery from the front as well.

Team NuCanoe Ohio - http://www.kayakcorral.com/ - http://www.steelheadshop.com/
Forum Timezone: America/Los_Angeles

Most Users Ever Online: 131

Currently Online: CrappieFly, Jim Mcc, Chaz
19 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

ack-yak: 2605

CrappieFly: 2570

dinosaur: 1512

Owl Jones: 762

crayfish: 641

Nobody: 602

danO: 477

Kayak_and_crossbones: 445

Phantom: 358

Dave K: 340

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 41

Members: 903

Moderators: 0

Admins: 2

Forum Stats:

Groups: 2

Forums: 14

Topics: 1865

Posts: 19609

Newest Members: Don, monstermagnet, Liz, Oldernie, Eddy G, bodidly, The Sea, Squatchaholic, cloudscreeker, Breaking_Shimanos

Administrators: Blake (18), NukeCanoe (1606)